Menu of Hotel Bradford Brew House and Beer Garden in Sayre, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Nestled in the heart of Sayre, PA, the Hotel Bradford Brew House and Beer Garden stands out as a genuine gem in the bar & grill scene. This cozy yet vibrant spot melds the warmth of a home bar with the flavors of expertly crafted comfort food. The menu showcases a thoughtful selection of sandwiches and shareable plates that cater to both casual diners and dedicated food lovers.

The Bacon Cheeseburger Sub is undoubtedly a star on the menu, delivering a hearty blast of smoky bacon and melted cheese tucked inside a satisfying sub roll, perfectly paired with crispy fries. Equally impressive are the various cheesesteak options that elevate this classic to an art form. From the Italian style, with its rich marinara topping, to the Sirloin Steak Cheesesteak Sub loaded with sautéed onions, peppers, and American cheese on a fresh Mastracchio roll, each bite speaks to care and quality.

For those seeking bold, layered flavors, the Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak is a must-try. It balances spicy buffalo sauce with tender chicken and the ubiquitous cheese, rounded out by golden garlic fries that add an irresistible crunch and aroma. The BLT Sandwich served with house chips offers a lighter, but equally well-executed choice for those who prefer classic simplicity.

Beyond sandwiches, the menu’s flatbread pizzas and quesadillas provide excellent options for sharing or a casual meal. The flatbread varieties — cheese, pepperoni, garlic, or pickle — each deliver a crisp, flavorful crust with thoughtfully layered toppings, while the chicken or beef quesadillas offer hearty, melty satisfaction at a fair price.

What transforms the dining experience here isn’t just the food, but the atmosphere and service. Patrons like Seth Hazen highlight the personalized care from the team — from knowledgeable beer flights skillfully described by staff like Kacey to the attentive service of Bre, ensuring guests feel valued and right at home. This sense of community permeates the space, making it a place not just to eat, but to relax and connect.

The homemade elements — such as the blue cheese dressing accompanying the Carolina wings — are standout touches that elevate classic bar fare into memorable dishes. The Garlic Dilly Burger Sliders, paired with house-made ranch, have left diners speechless, underscoring the kitchen’s commitment to flavor creativity and quality. Kudos to Mitch, the kitchen’s heartbeat, whose craft ignites the menu with just the right amount of heat and finesse.

Families will appreciate the kid-friendly options and quick service, making it an inviting stop for all ages. The brew house also shines with seasonal offerings like alcoholic slushes in summer and engaging events like trivia nights year-round, which further cement its role as a community hub.

In sum, the Hotel Bradford Brew House and Beer Garden is a compelling blend of comfort, character, and culinary skill. Its menu is crafted with precision and passion, reflected in every sandwich, wing, and brew poured. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this establishment is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, satisfying bar & grill fare served with genuine hospitality.